The 6 Best Crappie Jig Colors To Catch More Crappie

John Malcolm
John MalcolmPublished: May 3, 2023
The 6 Best Crappie Jig Colors To Catch More Crappie

Are you passionate about crappie fishing and eager to enhance your skills? If so, you must know that selecting the right bait is one of the most significant factors in catching crappie.

More specifically, choosing the perfect color when crappie jig fishing could be the difference between a successful and unfruitful day on the water.

With a variety of colors available to choose from, selecting the best crappie jig color may be puzzling.

Luckily, we've come up with valuable insights and researched the six best crappie jig colors to help you catch more crappie—

  • White
  • Chartreuse/White
  • Shad Patterns
  • Black/Blue
  • Glow Colors
  • Green Pumpkin

While those are the best colors, they each have different uses.

Understanding the importance of selecting the right crappie jig color.

When it comes to crappie fishing, the right crappie jig color can make or break your day on the water. As a pro angler, I've seen many struggles with catching crappie because they overlooked the importance of jig color selection.

Water clarity and lighting are critical factors in determining the crappie jig color to use. In murky or muddy water, bright colors like fluorescent green do the trick. These colors catch the fish's eye and draw them towards the bait. On the other hand, natural-looking crappie jig colors like baby shad or minnows work best in clear water.

Crappie fish rely on sight to feed, so if they cannot see your bait, they won't bite. Choosing the right color is crucial whether you are using a lure or a jig head. So, do not hesitate to experiment with different crappie jig colors. It will be worth it when you get your catch of the day.

The top 6 crappie jig colors consistently catch big crappie.

When it comes to crappie fishing, the right jig color is critical. If you want to catch more fish on your next outing, pay close attention to the color of your crappie jig. And if you're unsure where to start, here are the top six crappie jig colors that consistently prove successful for anglers.

Lure ColorDescriptionIdeal Conditions
WhiteWhite jigs, especially with black speckles, are effective in murky water due to their contrasting colors.Murky water
Chartreuse/WhiteA bright combination that is attractive to crappie, particularly effective in clear water.Clear water
Shad PatternsMimics the appearance of shad with silver and gray hues, a favorite prey among many crappie species.General use, especially in natural settings
Black/BlueCreates a bright contrast in dark, murky conditions, standing out in muddy water.Dark, murky water
Glow ColorsFluorescent green or yellow, ideal for night fishing or low visibility, reflecting light to attract fish.Night fishing, low visibility, deeper water
Green PumpkinVersatile and intriguing, not a natural color but highly effective in various conditions.Various conditions, versatile use

We definitely recommend you try a variation of these colors when you're out fishing for crappie. As always, don’t be afraid to experiment with different jig colors and sizes until you find the one that works best for your conditions.

When to use bright or fluorescent crappie jig colors.

SouthBend Handcrafted Crappie Fishing Jigs
  • Use bright or fluorescent jig colors like white and pink in murky water and low light to attract crappie.
  • Match jig colors to natural prey and consider time of day, using colors like chartreuse during sunrise or sunset.

Fishing in murky or deep water can be a challenging task. But did you know that brighter crappie jig colors can surprisingly increase your success rate?

These bright colors act as a magnet, catching the crappie's attention even in low-visibility waters. For instance, shades like white, blue ice, or bright pink are sure to trigger a strike.

It's not only the water that affects the jig colors but also the weather. During sunrise or sunset, the sun's angle and intensity can cause a glare on the water's surface, making it harder for crappie to detect subtler colors.

So, in these conditions, fluorescent yellow or chartreuse color can be an absolute game-changer.

However, before selecting the color of the bait, you must consider the natural colors of the crappie's prey.

You don't want to scare the fish away with a bright color that doesn't match their feeding habits. Although, if that green pumpkin is any indicator, you might not scare them at all.

In fact, you might entice them. Finding the right balance between standing out and blending in can be the key to success. Don't hesitate to experiment with different crappie jig colors and see which ones work the best in your fishing spots.

Natural-looking crappie jig colors that mimic prey.

  • Natural-looking jig colors, such as chartreuse and brown, mimic crappie prey like shad, minnows, and crawfish, increasing the likelihood of attracting and catching crappie.
  • Chartreuse is effective in clear water for its reflective qualities, while brown or crawdad colors are ideal in murky waters, standing out against the dark background.
  • Successful crappie fishing involves experimenting with jig colors that resemble natural prey, adapting to different water conditions and clarity.

Crappie are known for their impressive eyesight, making them highly skilled sight feeders.

If you're going to catch crappie, using natural-looking jig colors that emulate prey is essential. This can trick the crappie into thinking that your lure is the real deal.

One color that has proven effective time after time is chartreuse.

This particular shade imitates small baitfish like shad and minnows, making it highly appetizing to the crappie. In clear water, its beautiful shine and glimmer catch the crappie's eye from a much greater distance.

Another natural-looking color that works like a charm is brown or crawdad colors.

This shade looks like the color of crawfish, which is a favorite food for crappie. Brown jigs work excellently in muddy or murky waters, where the color stands out perfectly against its dark background.

The key to catching crappie is to put yourself in their shoes and act like a professional crappie angler. Experiment with various crappie jig colors that imitate prey and see which ones work best in different water clarities and light conditions.

The benefits of experimenting with different crappie jig colors.

Fishing enthusiasts widely rely on a crappie jig to catch a particular type of fish. The color of the jig often depends on a person's preferences, but experimentation is key to finding what works best. Trying out different colors can improve your catch rate and boost your chances of having a successful trip.

Mixing and matching different crappie jig colors is like embarking on a scientific adventure on the water. It helps you learn what's effective and what isn't in different situations. With so many variables like the weather, seasons and water clarity levels, you will never run out of options for experimentation. There might also be a particular size or type of jig head that works better with certain colors. So, dare to experiment, and you could find your "Eureka!" moment.

Apart from the benefits of catching more fish, trying out different colors makes fishing more exhilarating and less humdrum. A day on the lake is never wasted when you find new and exciting ways to fish. Plus, no two crappies are the same, and every water body is unique. So, it's essential to adjust your methods and colors accordingly to get the most out of your fishing experience.

Don't shy away from experimenting with a variety of crappie jig colors if you want to catch more fish consistently. Keep in mind that the right color jig could mean the difference between a fruitful fishing trip and a lousy one.

When you find color combinations that work wherever you're fishing, stick with it.

Tips for successfully fishing with crappie jigs of various colors.

As an avid crappie angler, you are always looking for ways to improve your chances of catching more fish.

Experimentation with lure colors.

One helpful tip is to experiment with different crappie jig colors until you find the ones that work best for the water conditions you are fishing in and for the time of day.

The right size jig head.

Another crucial tip to keep in mind is to always match the size of the jig head to the size of the crappie you are trying to catch. For instance, using small jig heads would be ideal for shallow waters where crappie are smaller.

Vary the depth.

Varying the depth of your jigging technique to match the feeding depth of crappie would enable you to find the right color jig for the fish you are trying to catch. For example, if we're fishing in shallow waters, we would want to go with lighter colors that can be seen easily by the fish.

Know the environment.

One important factor to consider is the color of the jig. When fishing in clear water, it is advisable to use more natural-looking colors, such as baby shad or other small fish that crappie feed on in their natural environment. But in muddy water, it would be best to use brighter colors like blue ice and other fluorescent colors that stand out in low visibility.

Time of the year.

It is essential to pay attention to the time of year and the crappie spawn cycle. During the spawn, crappie become sight feeders, so bright colors can be more effective. That's not to say that natural-looking jigs won't work, but it's important to keep in mind the fish's behavior.

Catching fish with the best crappie baits.

Selecting the perfect crappie jig color can make or break your fishing trip- it's the difference between a lazy afternoon by the water and hauling a boatload of fish back home.

With a little bit of experimentation and an understanding of key factors, you can drastically improve your chances of crappie-catching success.

It's important to keep in mind the water clarity, size of the jig head, and behavior of the fish when selecting your crappie jig color. Don't be afraid to mix it up based on the season, time of day, and other variables.

John Malcolm

John Malcolm

Expert Angler

John is a highly skilled angler with over two decades of experience and a passion that has led him to participate in numerous tournaments, including reeling in a remarkable 9lb bass on Lake Okeechobee. His dedication to fishing and willingness to share his expertise make him a respected ambassador for the angling community, inspiring others to appreciate the sport.